NYSE American and NYSE Arca adopt rules for binary options on company metrics such as iPhone sales
The two exchanges' rules mirror Cboe's SEC-approved contracts, which pay $1 or nothing depending on a company's reported sales, earnings or other metric.
By Ideas Desk ·
The short version
- SEC notices published November 18 show NYSE American and NYSE Arca filed rules on November 4 to list binary options on metrics reported by 23 companies (our count), SpaceX among them.
- Each contract pays a fixed $1 or nothing, depending on how the figure in the company's earnings filing with the SEC compares with the strike level.
- Both exchanges call their rules substantively identical to Cboe's, which the SEC approved on October 13 after finding the contracts are options on a security.
- Kalshi and Rothera questioned that approach in letters to the SEC. The agency noted that similar products may be structured differently and be subject to CFTC jurisdiction.
- Neither exchange will list the contracts until a clearing agency is ready and other steps are complete; comments are due December 9.
NYSE American and NYSE Arca have adopted rules to list binary options tied to figures that companies report each quarter, from diluted earnings per share to iPhone sales and Tesla's Model 3/Y production. The Securities and Exchange Commission published notices of both changes in the Federal Register on November 18, 2026 (NYSE American, NYSE Arca). The exchanges filed them on November 4 as changes that take effect on filing, and each calls its version "substantively identical" to the contracts the SEC approved for Cboe Exchange in October.
The NYSE filings present the product as a simple way to take a view on, or hedge, a single figure in a company's results.
How the contracts work
A binary KPI option (KPI stands for key performance indicator) is cash-settled and European-style, so it can be exercised only at expiration, and it pays a fixed $1 or nothing. A call pays if the metric the company reports equals or exceeds the strike level; a put pays if the figure comes in below it. The contracts expire on the day the company releases its results for the period, and the payout is decided by the value in the company's earnings filing with the SEC (a Form 8-K, 10-Q or 10-K), not by its press release. A later restatement does not change a contract that has already settled.
Each contract has a multiplier of one, against 100 for a standard stock option. Position limits are 25,000 standard contracts per expiration, with 100 binary contracts counting as one. The exchanges call the fixed $1 payout reasonable given what they describe as the "retail nature" of the product.
Which companies are on the lists
Both exchanges name the same 23 issuers, by our count, among them Apple, Amazon, Microsoft, NVIDIA, JPMorgan Chase, Netflix, Coinbase and SpaceX. The notices give the selection test, which NYSE Arca attributes to Cboe's filing: in May 2026 each company had a market value above $3 billion and ranked among the 200 U.S. companies with the highest average daily trading volume in their stock or options. SpaceX, not yet trading in May 2026, is the exception; the exchanges expect it to qualify on its first month of trading, citing about 290 million shares a day from June 12 to June 22, 2026, and a $2.145 trillion market value on June 22, figures NYSE Arca credits to Cboe.
| Company | Metrics listed include |
|---|---|
| Apple | Diluted earnings per share; total net sales; iPhone net sales; Services net sales |
| Alphabet | Revenues; YouTube ads revenues; Google Cloud revenues |
| Meta Platforms | Revenue; advertising revenue; Family Daily Active People |
| Tesla | Total revenues; Model 3/Y production; Supercharger connectors; free cash flow |
| Palantir Technologies | Revenue; net income; closed deals of at least $1 million |
| Robinhood Markets | Total net revenues; funded customers; Robinhood Gold subscribers |
| SpaceX | Diluted earnings per share; total revenues |
Why the SEC approved Cboe's version
In its October 13 order approving Cboe's rules, the SEC found that the contracts are options on a security under the Securities Exchange Act. Its reasoning: reported results move a company's share price, so an option on those results should move with the stock.
Not every commenter agreed, the order shows. Kalshi Inc. questioned Cboe's reliance on an earlier SEC order on credit default options because that order came before the Dodd-Frank Act. Rothera Exchange and Clearing argued that the contracts do not settle on the price or value of a security, and that the SEC should hold off because it and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission had jointly asked for comment on how swaps are defined. Robinhood, by contrast, agreed that the exchange-listed contracts are securities options and, as the order summarizes its letter, said they would let investors hedge risks in single metrics that existing options cannot isolate efficiently.
The SEC answered that deciding what counts as a security is within its own authority, and that once it found the proposal consistent with the act, the law required it to approve. It also acknowledged that similar products built on the same metrics "may be structured in different ways and be subject to CFTC jurisdiction".
The NYSE exchanges argue that similar contracts already trade over the counter and on platforms that are not registered securities exchanges, and that an exchange listing adds central clearing, price transparency and SEC oversight.
What happens next
Trading has not started. Each exchange says it will not list the contracts until a registered clearing agency is ready to clear them, the required options disclosure document is in place, needed changes involving FINRA and industry-wide systems and plans are complete, and members have been notified. Once it designates the clearing agency, which could be the Options Clearing Corporation or another registered one, it will file a separate rule change.
The changes took effect on filing, but under the rule the exchanges used they may not become operative until 30 days after filing, December 4 by our count, unless the SEC sets a shorter period; neither notice records one. The SEC takes comments until December 9, 2026, and may suspend either change within 60 days of the November 4 filing, a window that by our count runs to January 3, 2027; a suspension would send the rules into proceedings on whether to approve or disapprove them.
Sources
- Self-Regulatory Organizations; NYSE American LLC; Notice of Filing and Immediate Effectiveness of Proposed Change To Amend Its Rules To Permit the Listing of Binary Options Overlying Key Performance Indicators (FR Doc. 2026-23425) U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Federal Register (GovInfo), November 18, 2026
- Self-Regulatory Organizations; NYSE Arca, Inc.; Notice of Filing and Immediate Effectiveness of Proposed Rule Change To Amend Its Rules its Rules To Permit the Listing of Binary Options Overlying Key Performance Indicators (FR Doc. 2026-23427) U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Federal Register (GovInfo), November 18, 2026
- Self-Regulatory Organizations; Cboe Exchange, Inc.; Notice of Filing of Amendment No. 1 and Order Granting Accelerated Approval of a Proposed Rule Change, as Modified by Amendment No. 1, To Permit the Listing of Binary Options Overlying Key Performance Indicators Reported by Certain Issuers of Stock (FR Doc. 2026-21149) U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Federal Register (GovInfo), October 16, 2026
Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then checked against the 3 sources above in a separate fact-check on November 18, 2026. Spotted an error? Tell us.